Athletic Injuries to
the Leg, Foot and Ankle
The first recorded athletic injury appeared in Genesis 32:24-24...
“So Jacob was left alone, and a man wrestled with him till daybreak. When the man saw that he could not overpower him, he touched the socket of Jacob's hip so that his hip was wrenched as he wrestled with the man.”
Galen (second century AD) was first sports physician to the gladiators.
Sports injuries are incredibly common and most occur in the lower limb. There are estimated 350 ankle sprains in Sydney each day.
Chronic Leg Pain
Well known list of differential diagnoses in decreasing order of frequency...
- Chronic compartment syndrome
- Medial tibial stress syndrome
- Stress fractures
- Gastrocnemius strain
- Nerve entrapment syndromes
- Venous disease
- Arterial occlusion
- Fascial herniation
- Tendonitis Radiculopathies
Diagnosis is often helped by history and examination.
Chronic Compartment Syndrome
A muscle that swells in it's confined fascial space. Most common in the anterior compartment, followed by deep posterior, lateral and superficial posterior (Martens and Meyersons Sports Med. 9:62 1990).
Diagnose with measurement of resting and exertional pressures.
- A good history
- Resting Pressure > 15 mmHg (Normal 0 - 8)
- An exercise pressure > 75 mmHg is diagnostic
- 1 min post exercise > 30mmHg
- 5 - 10 min post exercise > 15 mmHg
Live with the pressures or have a fasciotomy.
Medial Tibial Stress Syndrome
A stress reaction alone with the postero-medial aspect of the tibia variously attributed to the fascia, periosteum or bone. A heterogeneous entity which may involve the attachment of soleus, periostitis beneath the tibialis posterior, a stress reaction on the tibia or even the flexor digitorum longus muscle overuse.
Diagnose with a bone scan and do not confuse with deep posterior compartment syndrome.
Modification of activities, NSAIDS. Role of surgery is controversial. Most surgical proponents combine a deep posterior fasciotomy with release of the fibrous arch of the soleus and claim 80% good or excellent results (Jarvinnen et al. Int. J. Sports Med. 10:55. 1989).
Occurs in middle aged tennis players who suddenly extend their knee with their ankle in full dorsiflexion. Manage with initial rest the stretching and strengthening to regain function.
Nerve Entrapment Syndromes
Superficial peroneal the most common. Most nerves have been described such as posterior tibial, saphenous, sural and common peroneal as it transverses the neck of the fibula. Patients will describe a pain that is burning, tingling and often radiating.
Local therapy such as NSAID creams, amytryptyline, surgical release combined with fasciotomy.
|Popliteal Artery Entrapment Syndrome
A relatively rare entity that causes pain in athletic individuals. Cause is anatomical variations in the course of the popliteal artery leading to compression. Delaney and Gonzalez Surgery 69:96 1971). May be difficult to differentiate from exertional compartment syndrome. May produce a picture similar to intermittent claudication.
Diagnose with bi-planar arteroigraphy performed after exercise.
Lateral Ankle And Ligament Injury
The most common orthopaedic injury. One per 10,000 population per day, ie 350 in Sydney today!
Ligaments involved are the anterior talo-fibular ± the calcaneofibular. Bostrum believed that isolated tears of the calcaneofibular ligament were very rare.
Mechanism of injury is a plantar flexion-inversion sprain.
I - Stretch
II - In between I and III
III - Complete rupture
Treat all non-operatively in my opinion (no significant difference between cast, operative repair and controlled early mobilisation) looking at re-injury, functional instability, range of motion, pain/swelling/stiffness, return to pre-injury activity.
Rest Ice Compression Elevation works well - non weight bearing with crutches or weight bearing in an aircast(r) brace for the first few days, the range of motion exercises and proprioceptive retraining.
Of interest is that the subjective and objective stability don't correlate.
Outcome In Military Recruits
Grade I - 8 days
Grade II - 15 days
Grade III - 21 days +
In workers compensation double these times.
Chronic instability is easily dealt with by delayed ligament reconstruction with > 90% good results
|Sources Of Continuing Pain
Or Instability After Ankle Sprain
Posterior tibial tendon
Peroneal tendon (tear or dislocation)
Posterior tibial tendon
Other Ligamentous Injury
Anterior tibial osteophyte
Anterior inferior tibiofibular ligament
Failure to regain normal motion (Tight TA)
Accessory soleus muscle
Normal X-Ray does not equal normal ankle.
Current Concepts review on ankle sprains: JBJS 73A, 305 1991.
|Osteochondral lesions of the talus
Also known as osteochondral fractures of the talus, talar dome lesion, osteochondritis dissecans.
Aetiology - trauma or spontaneous osteonecrosis?
9% of “chronic ankle sprains”
Medial > lateral
Age 20 - 30
Bilateral about 10%
Medial are mid or posterior 1/3 and deep
Lateral are mid or anterior 1/3 and shallow
Classification Modified (Berndt and Hartly JBJS 41a:988. 1959)
X-ray based though appearance at arthroscopy/CT or MRI is more useful
I Small trabecular compression fracture without displacement
II Partially detached osteochondral fragment (IIA Cyst formed)
III Fully detached osteochondral fragments remaining in its bed
IV Completely detached fragment of loose body
Plain x-rays are usually normal - therefore Clinical Suspicion Bone scan then CT or MRI.
CT scan image of a cyst in the talus may be traumatic and indicates chronicity - see image below...
Arthroscopic treatment a great advance
Unroof lesion, curette out loose fragments
NWB 2 weeks if lesion < 1.5cm
NWB 6 weeks if lesion > 1.5cm
Read Anderson et al JBJS 71A:1143. 1989. (Good Australian paper)
|Anterolateral Gutter Synovitis / Impingement
Described by Wolin in 1950.
Recently popularised by Richard Ferkel of Van Nuys California.
The Sequence Of Events Postulated Is
Iinflamed ligament ends
Chronic ankle sprain
Ferkel claims 84% good or excellent results in 75 patients with >2 year folow-up.
Fractures Of The 5th Metatarsal Base
The most common foot and ankle fracture.
There are essentially two types:
1. Tuberosity fractures - very common
2. “Jones” fractures - less common
Tuberosity fractures may or may not involve the 5th tarsometatarsal joint. Theories of aetiology include peroneus bevis avulsion and avulsion by the lateral fibres of the plantar ligament.
Most patients will give the history of an inversion injury.
Tuberosity Fractures Management
Management is symptomatic. I recommend either a post-operative shoe or an aircast weightbearing. If the patient is in too much pain to weight-bear then a period non-weightbearing on crutches is suggested. Disability rarely lasts longer than 6 weeks. Non-union is rarely a problem as fibrous pseudoarthrosis is usually painless. For a displaced intra-articular fracture surgery should be considered.
The Jones Fracture
Named after Robert Jones who in 1902 described a fracture he sustained whilst dancing (approximately three-quarters of an inch from the fifth metatarsal base”. He made no comment on the preferred method of treatment though stated that his disability was considerable. Vascular studies have shown this area to be a watershed and therefore the incidence of delayed/non union is explained.
Jones Fracture Management
The acute fracture is best treated initially with six weeks non-weightbearing in a cast. The majority of “fresh” fractures will heal with this regime. If union fails to occur then intramedullary fixation with a screw and a bone graft is suggested.
A common injury that is surprisingly frequently missed. Acute rupture most common in males between the ages of 30 and 50 “Weekend warriors” more often than trained athletes though not always the case. Painful prodrome is volunteered if asked.
Obvious? No! 25% are missed by the first treating physician.
History is characteristic and involves a sudden severe pain in the back of the ankle “like being struck with a tennis ball” with or without an associated loud pop.
Physical examination - feel for the gap.
Thompson or Simmonds test.
CAUTION: DO NOT TRUST ULTRASOUND OR MRI... THE DIAGNOSIS IS CLINICAL.
The slide below shows a complete rupture of the achilles tendon at surgery - the ultrasound was reported as showing a partial tear.
Controversy existed regarding operative vs Non-operative treatment. The considerations include ultimate strength, length, re-rupture and the sometimes disastrous complications of surgery. In general surgical reconstruction is favoured as the rate of re-rupture is less and the functional length of the tendon is easier to restore. In young athletic patients the re-rupture rate following non-operative treatment is unacceptable (10% vs 2%).
The rehabilitation is undergoing change and a trend is developing towards earlier mobilisation with better outcomes with respect to strength and rates of re-rupture.
Chronic TA Rupture or Missed TA Rupture
Indications for surgery are persistent pain and weakness. The operative procedures are not without their morbidity and all operations are a compromise.
Relative Strength Of Muscles
Penroneus Brevis 2.6
Second MTP Joint Synovitis
Described in the last 15 years
Thought due to mechanical overload
Presents with associated instability of the joint
Diagnosis is clinical
Think of associated arthropathy (Seronegative in young males)
Tape the toe
3/4 length insole metatarsal dome
Judicious use of steroid injection
Far more common than pilon fractures and also much easier to treat. The mechanism of injury varies and was elegantly described in Lauge-Hansen in his classic series of articles in the 1950's. The commonest ankle fracture is the so-called supination external rotation injury. The first word (supination) describes the position of the foot and the subsequent movements (external rotation), the mechanism of injury. Other common mechanisms are pronation-abduction and supination-abduction. These particular injuries produce characteristic fracture patterns according to the degree of injury.
Classification Of Ankle Fractures
The Dennis-Weber Classification is the most commonly used system because it is easily recalled, it pertains to the relation ship of the fibular fracture to the syndesmosis...
A - Below the syndesmosis
B - At the syndesmomsis
C - Above the syndesmosis
The AO group has dominated thinking about ankle fractures for the last 20 years. The fibular has been the focus of attention with early biomechanical work stating it's weight-bearing role and the detrimental effects of even small alterations in it's position (Ramsey and Hamilton [ii]).
Such an approach behooves the surgeon to operate on almost every ankle fracture as displacements of even 1 mm are not tolerated. Recent research is giving the medial side greater prominence and suggests that earlier concepts of the fibular as the main stabilizer of the ankle were erroneous (iii). Indeed, syndesmotic injury in the absence of medial injury has been shown not to affect talar displacement in a cadaver model (iv)
1. With an intact medial side no advantage has been shown (operative vs. Non-operative) in the management of isolated fractures of the lateral malleolus.
2. In bi-malleolar fractures, an anatomical reduction has been shown to correlate best with a successful outcome. This is of course most easily achieved surgically according to AO principles of rigid internal fixation with early joint mobilisation.
3. In Weber C injuries (with medial disruption) a syndesmotic screw should be considered in injuries > 3 cm above the plafond. Use a 4.5 mm screw engaging 3 or 4 cortices and not lagged.
4. In posterior malleolar fractures involving > 25% of the joint, anatomical reduction is recommended. I prefer the posterolateral approach with the patient in the lateral decubitus position.
I - Lauge-Hansen N, Fractures of the ankle II. Combined experimental-surgical and experimental-roentgenologic investigations. Arch Surg 69: 957-985. 1950.
II - Ramsey PL Hamilton W, Changes in tibio-talar area of contact caused by lateral shift. JBJS 58A: 356, 1976.
III - Michelson JD, Current concepts review, Fractures about the ankle. JBJS 77A, 142. 1995.
IV - Boden SD, Labropoulos PA, McCowin P, Lstini WF, and Hurwitz SR, Mechanical considerations for the syndesmosis screw JBJS 71A: 1548. 1989.